?

Log in

Previous Entry | Next Entry

are children human?

From WAKSLER, Frances. C. (1986) Studying Children: Phenomenological Insights. Human Studies, 9, 71-82.

"An anonymous reviewer of Mandell's work (Mandell, 1984a) in a rather vituperative set of comments, saw her claims of children's competence as self-evidently erroneous and as evidence of her incompetence. The reviewer asserted, without substantiation, that "children ARE cognitively immature" and "do NOT yet possess the social skills appropriate for independent social living." Indeed this reviewer accused her of "anthropomorphising" children" (p.72).




Comments

( 1 comment — Leave a comment )
arcana_mundi
Aug. 9th, 2008 01:24 am (UTC)
Great googly moogly. Anthropomorphising children? As opposed to...

Neat share, thanks!
( 1 comment — Leave a comment )

Profile

attackademia
When Academics Attack! Quotes and marginalia.

One rule to ring them all.

Only one rule: post only quotations from published material or amusing glosses - do not attempt to start fresh, UNPUBLISHED fights with each other in the comments while attempting to justify, explain, or temporize for, an attackademic in your field.

Anything that starts to look serious or pedantic will be deleted on the grounds that it will threaten to turn things deadly dull. WWF-style (or similar) rooting only. If you want to colloq, TAKE IT OUTSIDE OF THE THUNDERDOME.

Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com